Kohli for India is a necessity, not a debate

Virat Kohli for RCB
Virat Kohli for RCB (PC: X)

As the IPL 2024 season gathers steam, the anticipation among Indian cricket aficionados is palpably shifting towards the upcoming T20 World Cup in the West Indies and USA. Central to their debates and speculation is the role of Virat Kohli, whose place in the squad has become a hot topic. Critics argue that Kohli’s style may not align with the aggressive batting ethos dubbed the “modern T20” approach. This article delves into a nuanced analysis of Kohli’s performance for RCB this year, using it as a lens to evaluate his suitability for the Indian T20 squad. Through a detailed examination, we aim to shed light on where Kohli stands in relation to the evolving dynamics of international T20 cricket.

A potential counterargument to Kohli’s inclusion based on his run tally could focus on the overall performance of Royal Challengers Bengaluru (RCB). Despite Kohli’s impressive 316 runs at a strike rate of 146.29, RCB has seen the least number of wins among the top teams. Given that cricket is quintessentially a team sport, it’s unfair to place the burden of victory solely on one player. RCB’s bowling struggles have been evident, yet this discussion remains centred on batting, especially considering Kohli’s inclusion in the World Cup squad would mean another batter missing out.

Most Runs in IPL 2024 so far
Most Runs in IPL 2024 so far (PC: BCCI/IPL)

The graphic provided reveals that among the top five run-scorers, two belong to Gujarat Titans (GT) and two to Rajasthan Royals (RR), indicating a more balanced team performance supporting their achievements. In contrast, Kohli’s efforts stand out more singularly for RCB. Excluding two specific matches against CSK and LSG where Kohli’s contributions were 13.13% and 15.49% of RCB’s total runs respectively, his contributions in the remaining games soared above 46%. Given a lineup that includes formidable batters like Faf Du Plessis, Glenn Maxwell, and Cameron Green, it’s clear that a disproportionate share of the batting responsibility has fallen on Kohli. This situation likely led him to play more cautiously, restraining him from taking risks to avoid a collapse and emphasising his critical role and adaptability within the team.

Contribution in RCB's Totals so far
Contribution to RCB’s Totals so far (PC: BCCI/IPL)

For the Latest Sports News: Click Here

The argument that Kohli’s approach puts other RCB batters under undue pressure, potentially leading to their dismissals, warrants a detailed examination of his performances and their impact on his teammates. By dissecting his contributions in three specific matches, we can assess the validity of these claims.

Firstly, in the match against PBKS, an analysis of the partnerships reveals that Kohli’s strike rate (SR) remained above 100 in all five instances he was involved. Notably, among these, only during the fourth-wicket partnership did both Kohli and Rajat Patidar manage a strike rate of 100, while all other partners had strike rates below this threshold. This suggests Kohli maintained a consistent pace, not contributing to a slowdown that might pressure others.

Contribution vs PBKS
Contribution vs PBKS (PC: BCCI/IPL)

In the clash with KKR, Kohli’s performance was exemplary, with his strike rate in every partnership exceeding 133.33. He mirrored du Plessis’ strike rate of 133.33 and paired with Green to notch a strike rate of 152.38 against Green’s 157.14, indicating a closely matched performance without significant disparities. Kohli’s contribution never fell below 31 per cent in any partnership, and his strike rate never dipped below 108.33, underscoring his positive influence in these partnerships.

Contribution vs KKR
Contribution vs KKR (PC: BCCI/IPL)

The encounter against RR further cements Kohli’s vital role. His contributions were pivotal, never constituting less than 50 per cent of any partnership. Moreover, his strike rate consistently surpassed that of his batting partners in all four partnerships. This data compellingly illustrates that RCB’s batting strength significantly pivots around Kohli’s performances. These insights clearly demonstrate that the narrative of Kohli exerting pressure on other batters is misplaced. Instead, his consistent scoring and partnership-building underline his crucial role within the team. Given the dependency on him for anchoring the innings, it’s unreasonable to expect Kohli to play without a sense of caution. Far from being a liability, his strategic batting and ability to build partnerships are invaluable assets to RCB, highlighting his importance to not only his team but potentially the Indian T20 squad as well.

Contribution vs RR
Contribution vs RR (PC: BCCI/IPL)

Analysing the performances of the Indian T20 squad members against Afghanistan in this IPL season offers an enlightening perspective, particularly when considering the debate over selection. While Kohli as the highest scorer may not surprise many, given his current status as the Orange Cap holder, a deeper dive into the stats reveals more about the contention surrounding his inclusion in the T20 squad.

Remarkably, only three players from the squad that faced Afghanistan have managed to surpass the 200-run mark in this IPL season, and among them, Kohli is the sole batter exceeding 300 runs. This brings to light an essential aspect often overshadowed by the emphasis on strike rate (SR) – the fundamental importance of scoring runs.

When comparing strike rates among these prolific scorers, Kohli stands at 146.29, with Shubman Gill at 151.78 and Sanju Samson at 157.69. The differences in strike rate are relatively minor, especially when juxtaposed with the disparity in run accumulation. Kohli has outscored Gill by 61 runs and Samson by 70 runs, which underscores the critical role of run-scoring in the game’s shortest format.

Performance of India Players so far who played in the Afghanistan T20I series
Performance of India Players so far who played in the Afghanistan T20I series (PC: BCCI/IPL)

The debate over Kohli’s selection overlooks a fundamental cricketing truth: runs on the board matter. His superior ability to score, coupled with a strike rate that is competitive with the best in the IPL, makes the skepticism surrounding his selection perplexing, to say the least.

In conclusion, the discourse around Kohli’s inclusion in the T20 World Cup squad ought to shift from a question of suitability to an acknowledgement of necessity. His performances for RCB in the IPL 2024 are not just a testament to his enduring class but a compelling argument for his pivotal role in India’s quest for T20 glory. As the Indian team looks towards the T20 World Cup in the West Indies and the USA, having a player of Kohli’s calibre, experience, and resilience could be the keystone to navigating the pressures of the world stage. In the symphony of modern T20 cricket, Kohli’s bat orchestrates a melody that, while it may not always conform to the rapid rhythms of the perceived “new age” cricket, creates runs, wins matches, and, most importantly, inspires teams towards achieving greatness.

*Stats by Snehasis Mukherjee

Also Read: The Virat debate: Should Kohli make T20 World Cup cut?